• PSA,TAG, BGS Grading
  • Next day shipping available
  • Expert help on hand
  • Free shipping over $149.99

Savings worth signing up for.

How about 10% off?

Bestsellers

All the toys you'll ever need, in one place.

CollectibleTears Guarantee

Organized Shopping Experience

Stop digging through the noise and instantly lock onto the grails you need with our precision-curated, searchable inventory.

Fast Shipping

We treat every delivery like a high-stakes trade, using heavy-duty, protective packaging to ensure your hits arrive in pristine condition.

Top Tear Customer Service

From the moment you hit the site to the day the package touches your door, our team is locked in to ensure your hunt is smooth and professional.

TCG Grading Submission Service

Don’t let your best hits sit unprotected we handle the heavy lifting for your grading submissions, getting your cards from the binder to the 'Pristine 10' status they deserve.

Pro Membership

PERKS

Priority TCG Allocations: Skip the public waitlist and secure the hottest new booster boxes and special sets before they hit the shelves.

The Vault Access: Get private, early access to our curated inventory of high-end, rare, and "grail" single cards held exclusively for Syndicate members.

Slab Syndicate Grading Service: Elevate your hits with our streamlined, professional submission service, offering preferred pricing and priority handling to get your cards slabbed faster.

Rare Drop Alerts: Be the first to know the moment we acquire fresh collections or restock hard-to-find singles via direct member notifications.

The Metal Syndicate Pass: Your physical, serialized membership card—your official key to unlocking all Syndicate-only inventory and in-store perks.

Syndicate-Only Pricing: Enjoy exclusive, member-only discounts on all singles and sealed TCG inventory across the store.

Membership Tears

Collector (Free Tier)

The essential entry point for every fan of the culture.
✔ Exclusive member pricing

✔ Grading Status Updates

✔ Streamlined submission processing.

Ruby Tearrr ($99/Year)

Perfect for the active hunter building their collection daily.

✔All Free Perks included.

✔ 1.25 Points: Receive 1 for every $1 spent.

✔  Early Access Alerts Receive exclusive alerts on incoming stock.

✔ 1  Free One standard Collectible Tears grading-service fee waived each quarter.(Does not include insurance and shipping charges)

✔$2 off Collectible Tears’ service fee per card on submissions of 10–24 cards

Emerald Tear ($249.99/Year)

The VIP experience for serious volume hunters and fans.

✔All Ruby Tear Perks included.

✔ 1.5x points

✔ 8% Off eligible Singles

✔  Early Access Alerts: Sleeves, Top-loaders, and Binders.

✔ 1  Free One standard Collectible Tears grading-service fee waived each quarter.(Does not include insurance and shipping charges)

✔ $3 off Collectible Tears’ service fee per card
on submissions of 10–24 cards, 

✔ $4 off per card on submissions of 25+
cards 

✔ 1 Free Curated quarterly pack

Black Diamond Tear ($100/Year)

The ultimate "Black Card" for the elite investor and legacy collector.

✔ 2x points

✔ 10% Off eligible Singles

✔ First access to Vault inventory and allocations

✔ Early Access Alerts: Sleeves, Top-loaders, and Binders.

✔ 1  Free One standard Collectible Tears grading-service fee waived each month.(Does not include insurance and shipping charges)

 ✔ $4 off Collectible Tears’ service fee per card on submissions of 10–24 cards

 ✔ $5 off per card on submissions of 25–49 cards

 ✔ $6 off per card on submissions
of 50+ cards 

✔  Priority grading intake 

✔  1  Free Curated quarterly pack

Buy now

Why shop with us?

You're in good hands.

  • Over

    142k

    products sold

  • With

    99.6%

    positive reviews

  • New Members This Month

    12

    members

  • Fast shipping

    Ordered a game for my seven year old son and it arrived the next day. Super impressed with the speed and the careful packaging.

    Jordan Smith
    Seattle, Washington

  • Excellent service

    Great Service! Put the wrong shipping address and they promptly fixed it when asked and I still received the cards only 3 Days after ordering!!


    Taylor Christos
    Austin, Texas

  • Great selection

    Probably the best packaging I've had from an order, very sleek and
    condensed, and they had a pull tab to make getting the cards out of the
    large protective sleeve easier, of course they have their own sleeves
    too

    Alex Williams
    Venice, FL

  • Top quality

    The puzzle I bought exceeded my expectations. Top-notch quality, sleek design, and it came with puzzle mat!

    Sam Davis
    San Francisco, California

  • Reliable store

    Have ordered multiple times, always received exactly what was described. Products are genuine and fully functional.

    Casey Brown
    Denver, Colorado

  • User-friendly website

    Easy to navigate and make purchases. A hassle-free shopping experience with clear descriptions and transparent pricing.

    Riley Wilson
    Boston, Massachusetts

Collecting Shiny Cardboard Since '99

CollectibleToys


We’re here to ignite that obsession and fuel the relentless curiosity that comes with the hunt. Our curated vault of toys and collectibles isn't just about play it’s about the legendary moments, the rare finds, and the pure, unbridled joy of the game.

More about us